Chapter 1
A True Goodbye Leaves Without a Farewell
Brief
My girlfriend, Sienna Lawson, had been abroad for three months. On the day she returned, she walked out of the airport arm in arm with a man who looked strikingly similar to me.
That man was none other than her ex-boyfriend, Garrett Cain.
The tenderness she showed him was something I had never seen before.
It was then I realized I had been a stand-in for five years.
So, I chose to leave and disappear from her life.
In the end, Sienna, unable to find me, lost her mind.
Content
Watching Sienna step off the plane with Garrett Cain, the bouquet and umbrella in my hands slipped to the ground without me even noticing.
Cold raindrops pelted my face, but they were nothing compared to the icy chill in my heart.
I had seen a picture of Garrett in a suit on Sienna's phone once.
He looked a lot like me—maybe a 70% resemblance.
But I knew I wasn’t in the photo; I never wore suits.
Sienna had explained back then that she’d Photoshopped my face onto the image.
Even before I started dating her, I knew she had an ex who looked like me.
But after we got together, I figured the past was the past. She was with me now.
Seeing Garrett in person, though, everything clicked. I’d been a substitute for five years.
Friends who knew Garrett used to tease me:
“Ryan, your style—your clothes, hair—it’s starting to look a lot like Sienna’s ex-boyfriend Garrett’s.”
I had laughed it off then, thinking they were joking.
Looking back now at everything Sienna had done, the truth hit me.
In our five years together, she had me cut my hair the way she liked, dress the way she wanted, and eat the foods she liked.
But it wasn’t until today, when I saw Garrett with my haircut, wearing clothes like mine, and holding the very same soda crackers that Sienna always encouraged me to snack on, that it all made sense.
Standing in the rain, I felt like the fool in a viral internet meme.
I had loved her for five years. I had been Garrett’s stand-in for five years.
No wonder she went on frequent “business trips” abroad, sometimes for weeks. This time, it was three whole months.
Because Garrett had been abroad all this time.
During those three months, Sienna barely contacted me. I always sent “Good morning,” “Good afternoon,” and “Good night,” sharing every detail of my day. Her replies were always the same: “Yeah” or “Okay.”
It was exhausting.
I picked up the roses I’d dropped, looked at Sienna and Garrett laughing together, and let out a self-deprecating chuckle.
They were a perfect match.
I set the bouquet on a nearby public bench and drove home.
Once home, I took a hot shower to prevent a cold from being drenched in the rain, then collapsed into bed.
Predictably, I woke up the next day with a fever and pounding headache.
After taking cold medicine and notifying my boss I’d take the day off, I planned to rest. That’s when Sienna came home.
She walked in and looked at me, surprised. “Why didn’t you go to work?”
I glanced at her. “I took a sick day.”
She dropped her shopping bag on the couch, sat down, and demanded, “Why didn’t you pick me up yesterday? I told you to.”
My head throbbed, and I didn’t want to argue. “I’ve been busy. Forgot.”
She turned her head away in a huff, a familiar gesture to coax me into apologizing.
In the past, I’d rush to make things right within hours.
But now, I didn’t see the point. The fever and exhaustion made me want only to sleep.
I left her sulking and went to lie down.
Minutes later, furious, she barged into my room and threw the shopping bag onto the bed.
“I thought about you the whole time I was away. I ought you all these clothes, and you treat me like this?”
I glanced at the bag’s contents and let out a bitter laugh.
Of course. They were precisely Garrett’s style.