Chapter 3
Early Valentine’s Day, Tyler asked me to come downstairs.
He was holding a bouquet of red roses and a beautifully wrapped gift bag.
The moment he saw me, he gave me a big hug.
“Happy Valentine’s Day, babe. I can’t stay long, but we had to keep the tradition going, right?”
I thought I wouldn’t get to see him, but he’d clearly prepared a gift in advance.
We chatted briefly, and he left.
I happily went back to my dorm and opened the gift.
It was a YSL gift set.
My roommates gasped. “Wow, Harper, your boyfriend really spoils you!”
“He must’ve spent a lot. No wonder he’s been so busy. He’s been working extra to afford this!”
Tyler had given me what he thought was his very best.
I was pleased.
Jessie, my roommate and a beauty blogger, gave the box a long look but stayed quiet.
She had a sharp eye for quality, so when she didn’t react, the other two hesitated to keep praising.
“Jessie, is there something wrong?” I asked.
She picked up the lipstick, examining it with a hint of reluctance. “I’m not completely sure. Let me check with a friend.”
My heart sank.
I’d never thought much about fake products or the difference between genuine and counterfeit.
But if Jessie had doubts, there was a strong chance it was a fake.
Out of consideration, she offered to double-check with someone.
My other roommate consoled me, “Harper, maybe Tyler doesn’t know about luxury brands and got scammed.”
“Yeah, straight guys can’t tell the difference between real and fake products.”
They had a point.
I messaged Tyler, “Where did you buy this gift set?”
A few minutes later, he replied, “From the official store.”
He even attached a screenshot of the purchase record.
Could fake items show up in an official store?
Or maybe Jessie was wrong this time?
Tyler: “Is something wrong, babe? Don’t you like it?”
Me: “No, it’s great. Thank you.”
Tyler: “As long as you’re happy. I have to go tutor now, but let’s talk later, okay?”
Damon took me to Lakeside Amusement Park, but my thoughts were elsewhere.
Then, Jessie sent me another message, “It’s fake.”
She shared some comparison photos of real and fake products.
“Tyler probably bought it from an off-brand store.”
She even sent a link to a $100 YSL gift set that matched mine exactly.
“If he told you the truth, maybe he really thought YSL was that cheap. But if he’s lying, you should think twice about staying with him.”
I was at a loss for words.
I asked her, “Could the official store sell fakes?”
“No way. This set is so obviously fake. If an official store ever sold counterfeit goods, they’d at least make it harder to spot.”
But Tyler really did have a screenshot from the official store.
I sent it to Jessie.
She replied, “What if the official store gift wasn’t meant for you?”
Good point.
What if Tyler bought one from an off-brand store and one from the official store, one for me and one for someone else?
That would explain it.
But no—Tyler would never do something so low, right?
We’d been together for over a year. We were solid. He’d never betray me like that.
But just then, I spotted a familiar figure in the crowd.
It looked like Tyler.
Wasn’t he supposed to be tutoring? What was he doing here?