Chapter 3

6,321 words

When Ethan got into the car, he handed me a small box. Inside was a ruby necklace, the one he’d won at last month’s auction, along with that infamous engagement ring.

“Here. Don’t be mad. I’ve had this gift ready for a while. I’ve just been so busy lately, I forgot to give it to you.”

He spoke like he was pacifying a spoiled child throwing a tantrum.

“Let’s eat out for our anniversary this year,” I said flatly.

In the past, he’d always prepared a home-cooked meal, especially during those early years when we had very little. No matter what, he’d make sure we had a proper anniversary dinner.

Staring straight ahead, he started the car, casually responding, “Sure. Where do you want to go?”

He agreed too quickly—probably eager to free up more time to spend with her.

“How about Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria?”

The car skidded slightly. I pretended not to notice his fingers tense on the steering wheel.

“It’s snowing. The roads are slippery. Drive slow,” I said.

“Yeah,” he replied, trying to sound calm. Then, almost too casually, he asked, “Why there?”

“The new secretary recommended it. She says it’s her favorite. Why? Is there a problem?”

I asked with feigned innocence.

Ethan let out a barely audible sigh of relief.

“No, no problem.”

The rest of the drive was quiet.

I knew what was making him nervous. She was young, and she loved pizza and iced coffee. Lou Malnati’s was one of her go-to places. I’d seen it on her Facebook posts more times than I could count.

In those photos, I could always make out a faint reflection in the restaurant’s window—a silhouette of a man I knew too well, someone who had been by my side through so many years.

When we arrived, the place was packed, but the owner greeted Ethan warmly. When he saw me, his smile faltered for just a moment before becoming overly cheerful again.

“Do you come here often?” I asked.

He explained smoothly, “Some clients prefer a more casual setting for meetings.”

I couldn’t help but be impressed. Business had clearly taught him how to keep his composure. If I didn’t know him so well, I might’ve missed the subtle guilt behind his calm demeanor.

The waiter led us to a private booth, each room in the restaurant uniquely themed. This booth was where Jessica liked to take her photos.

Ethan ordered the half BBQ chicken and half smoked ribs combo.

But a mix-up happened, and they brought us the wrong dish—a spicy BBQ platter.

Ethan’s face darkened, and he quickly had them change it to the one we ordered, glancing at me nervously. When he saw that I wasn’t reacting, he seemed to relax.

Ethan had never been able to handle spicy food, and I always remembered to order something mild for him.

In Jessica’s photos, though, every plate was drenched in spicy sauce. I remembered one of her captions:

“He can’t handle spicy food, but he still came with me anyway. #TrueLove.”

“I heard you recently bought a ‘True Love’ engagement ring and had a wedding dress custom-made a year ago. Are those for me?” I asked abruptly.

Ethan flinched, dropping shrimp into my half of the platter by accident.

“No, a client requested those,” he said, calling the waiter for another order of shrimp.

I forced a weak smile, and though I could barely hold it together, I couldn’t stop myself from asking, “Ethan, are you ever going to marry me?”

He didn’t even look up, answering like it was a formality, “Of course. I promised you, didn’t I?”

He poured me a drink, clearly trying to soothe me, sensing my mood. “Emily, don’t overthink it. Weddings take a lot of planning. I want it to be perfect—it’s something you only get to do once in a lifetime.”

I stayed quiet, looking down at my phone, where Jessica had sent me photos just a few hours earlier.

She was wearing the Tiffany engagement ring, the custom Vera Wang wedding dress, smiling up at him, while he gazed lovingly back at her.

Ethan had said those exact same words to me years ago, back when he had nothing. His friends told him to marry me quickly so I wouldn’t leave him for someone better.

He’d refused, saying I deserved more.

He promised me a wedding that would make every woman in the world jealous.

But now, I knew—he wasn’t going to marry me.

I pulled up the photos and placed my phone in front of him. “Was your ‘client’ your secretary?”

I thought the evidence would make him panic, that he’d finally admit to everything.

But instead, he lit a cigarette, took several long drags, and finally muttered, “Jessica’s boyfriend died in a car accident. She said I remind her of him, so she asked me to take a photo with her. To give her closure.”

“There’s nothing going on between us.”

His words hit me like a punch to the gut. My eyes stung as the pain pierced through me.

“Ethan, if you really loved someone, you’d notice the smallest changes in them.”

“I’ve known for a while now that the person going to Lou Malnati’s with Jessica was you. Every time you came home, I could smell the barbecue sauce on you.”

“And you always smell like her perfume.”

Ethan sniffed his sleeve, his face growing pale.

“You used to never smoke around me.”

He stared at me, stunned, before quickly putting out his cigarette. Panic crept into his voice as he reached for me.

“Emily, let me explain—”

“Let me finish.”

I cut him off, my voice steady.

“I’ve been to this restaurant before. I tracked down the booth from her Facebook posts, and I asked the owner if I could reserve it.”

He had laughed and told me that the booth was always kept for a special guest. The man’s girlfriend loved this spot because of the view of the river. He didn’t want her to be disappointed if she couldn’t sit here on their next visit.

“Oh, and by the way, I’m allergic to shrimp.”

I picked up a piece of shrimp from the spicy platter, lifting my drink. “Mango juice too.”

“You’ve been mistaking me for her, haven’t you?”

Ethan’s face went ghostly white. His mouth opened, but nothing came out.

Tears finally spilled from my eyes as I let my voice break.

“Do you really think I didn’t know what you were doing during those two hours I waited for you?”

Ethan’s eyes widened, a flash of guilt crossing his face as he pulled me into his arms, begging.

“I’m sorry, Emily. I’m so sorry. I’ll fire her. I’ll never let her come near us again. Just please forgive me this time.”

“No.”

I shoved him away, screaming, “Ethan, I’ve already forgiven you once!”

Get the NovelMaster app → search code 527733Download NovelMaster