Chapter 4
I followed Ms. Harper silently down the hallway to the office.
Inside, Spencer Whitlock stood with his arms crossed, a smug smirk plastered across his face.
“Violet Sullivan, Spencer says he needs a one-on-one tutor,” Ms. Harper said, her tone neutral. “He claims you’ve been incredibly helpful and specifically requested you.”
I glanced at him. That infuriating smirk deepened, his arched brow practically daring me to react.
Such an immature stunt—exactly what I’d expect from someone like Spencer.
He’d handed himself over to me on a silver platter. Why would I say no?
The first tutoring session was in the library. I walked in with my books in hand, only to see Spencer seated at the table, wearing a faintly mischievous grin.
He really couldn’t hide anything. Every thought he had was written all over his face.
The moment I sat down, he snatched my pen and stuffed it up his sleeve, adopting an exaggerated look of innocence.
“Did you forget to bring a pen?” he asked.
I raised an eyebrow, then calmly pulled another pen from my pocket.
“I always come prepared,” I replied dryly.
Undeterred, he swiped at my books, sending them tumbling to the floor with a loud crash that drew annoyed looks from nearby students.
“Oops,” he said with a mock shrug.
As I bent to pick up my books, I said, “Do you ever get tired of this?”
“Not really,” he replied with an infuriating grin.
Just as I straightened, he snatched my notebook and pretended to fling it across the room.
I calmly reached into my bag and pulled out a pair of scissors, stabbing them into the table right in front of him.
“If you keep this up, my hand might slip next time,” I said coldly.
Spencer’s face drained of color, his confidence crumbling under my glare.
The second tutoring session was during study hall.
This time, he smeared glue on my chair before I arrived.
I immediately noticed the faint gleam of glue but said nothing. Circling behind him, I waited for my chance.
When his guard was down, I grabbed his backpack and dumped all its contents onto the floor.
“Violet Sullivan, are you crazy?” Spencer barked, leaping to his feet.
He seemed ready to throw a punch but froze when I held up my scissors, a wicked smile on my face.
“You enjoy playing games, right? Let’s see how you like it.”
His face turned bright red, but he didn’t dare retaliate.
By the time his lackeys scurried to help him gather his belongings, Spencer had completely forgotten about the glue.
He sat down without thinking and immediately regretted it.
I strolled up and leaned against his desk, grinning.
“Remember what I told you? ‘What goes around comes around.’”
Spencer gaped at me, unable to form a coherent response.
After failing twice to humiliate me, he finally gave up on his childish antics.
To my surprise, he started taking his studies seriously.
And when he did, the results were astounding. By the next exam, he ranked in the top ten of the class.
Ms. Harper practically beamed as she waved his score report in the air.
Even the Whitlocks were astonished at his sudden transformation.
A month later, I was invited to the Whitlock Estate.
It was the first time I’d seen my mother since school began.
Ivy was there too, glaring daggers at me with a venomous expression.
Spencer, on the other hand, greeted me with a shy, almost endearing smile as he led me to his study.
4.
At dinner, I finally met Mrs. Eleanor Whitlock, the lady of the house.
She exuded cold authority, but when speaking to me, her demeanor softened into something resembling kindness.
I knew better. She only saw me as useful.
Spencer chatted with me amiably throughout the meal, while Ivy silently fumed, her hands clenched so tightly her knuckles turned white.
Afterward, Ivy pulled me aside into the garden. Her expression was icy, her voice sharp.
“How are you doing this?”
I tilted my head in mock confusion.
“Doing what, Ivy?”
Of course, I knew exactly what she meant.
In our previous life, she had been sent to Oakridge Academy as Spencer’s study partner.
But Ivy had never been good at academics. She couldn’t keep up with the rigorous curriculum, let alone help Spencer.
Instead, she had suffered constant pranks and humiliation.
Too timid to stand up for herself, Ivy endured everything in silence, terrified of losing the Whitlocks’ support.
That fear had only emboldened Spencer, who escalated his torment until it culminated in an unforgivable act.
Drunk and careless, Spencer assaulted her before their senior year.
The Whitlocks had whisked them both away to Europe, trying to bury the scandal.
But Ivy’s suffering didn’t end there. She clung to Spencer like a lifeline, enduring unspeakable abuse until her death.
And yet, none of that had anything to do with me.
Back then, I’d had no choice—just as I hadn’t been given a choice now.
Our parents had always handed Ivy the best of everything, leaving me with scraps.
Even this time, Ivy had tried to push me into the fire, hoping I’d burn in her place.
But now that Spencer treated me with respect, her carefully hidden malice had finally spilled out.
“You think Spencer Whitlock is a good person? The Whitlocks don’t care about you. You’re just smart, that’s all. Stop acting so smug.”
I stared at her trembling, furious face.
“Is that all you’ve got to say, Ivy?”
Spencer appeared out of nowhere, his voice cold.
“Whatever you have to say about Violet is irrelevant. She’s under my protection.”
Ivy’s face went pale. Her fear of Spencer was deeply ingrained from our past life.
Watching their exchange, I felt nothing but disgust.
Without another word, I turned and went back inside, leaving them in the garden.
Watching my mother flatter Mrs. Eleanor Whitlock, showering her with praise about how “talented” her other daughter was, made me feel sick.
She was shamelessly pleading for Ivy Sullivan to be transferred to Oakridge Academy as well.
After relentless cajoling, Mrs. Whitlock finally relented, though her furrowed brow showed her displeasure.
I stood there, cold and detached, watching this farce unfold.
The wheels of fate had already turned. As long as I was in control, nothing would ever go back to how it was.
As for my so-called parents? Let them pin their hopes on their favorite daughter.
All I wanted was to live my life on my own terms.